09/10/2026
Two Watches
Dedicated to all XOs...
Before you read this story, I want to say one important thing. I have immense respect for my XO, Pyotr Nikolayevich, and my Skipper, Igor Kurdin, with whom I had the privilege to serve. But this tale is not about them at all, and contains no hidden hints. I thank God that fate brought me together with these men and that I had the chance to serve under them. It’s just that in the Navy, as in life, there are no two identical characters or two identical destinies. Each is its own story...
The story itself:
Thank God, not all retired officers who read my sea stories consider me a sellout bastard and a joint agent for the State Department, Mossad, and the NKVD all rolled into one.
Some send me direct messages. They correct me. They argue. They remind me of things I’ve already managed to forget. And sometimes they send their own stories.
One of them was told to me by a guy who left the Northern Fleet in the early nineties as a Senior Lieutenant [Lieutenant (j.g.)]. A story about his XO.
I won't name names. Not because it’s some big secret, but because a man has the right to be remembered not by his last name, but by his deeds.
On the boat, they quietly hated this XO. Especially the junior officers. As it turned out later, they hated a man they barely knew.
As was often the case on "boomers," the XO came from Weapons. On their missile boat he had once come up through the Weapons Department and had grown into the XO's billet as a man who knew the service from the inside out. Therefore, it was especially tough for those who served in that same department. The narrator was the Fire Control Officer in Weapons—a young Lieutenant (j.g.) for whom the digits in the tables represented calculations and data prep for a missile launch. For a regular XO, all this fire control wizardry might have been a thick enough forest that a junior officer could sometimes hide in it behind the word "system," a printout, or a smart-sounding term. With this guy, that didn't work. The XO himself came from there. The moment you'd say: "Commander, the fire control system..." he would cut you off:
"The system doesn't report to me. You report to me. Where'd the number come from?"
And then began what the whole crew called by various names, but never a kind one.
The XO entered the control room not as a human being, but as a surprise inspection. The Officer of the Deck (OOD) would snap to attention before he even realized why he was doing it, the Engineering Officer of the Watch (EOOW) would start staring at his panel as if seeing his own reactor plant for the very first time in his life, and the junior officer would instantly remember everything he hadn't done over the last three days. The XO would grab the logbook, flip through a few pages, and ask quietly: "What is this?"
It was exactly that quiet "What is this?" they feared most of all. It was usually followed by an investigation revealing that the entry was made twelve minutes late, the signature looked like the dying cardiogram of an octopus, and the guy who signed it, based on the totality of the evidence, shouldn't have been trusted with an electric kettle, let alone strategic missile weapons. Finishing up in the conn, the XO would head through the compartments. Under the deck plates, there'd be a drop of oil. In the bilges—a rag folded in a way that violated his concept of the universe. In the galley—a knife out of place. With the missile techs—log entries that could be interpreted two ways, and on a ballistic missile sub, he firmly believed, the only thing that could be interpreted two ways was a joke. Everything else had to have one meaning, one digit, and one signature. It felt like God built this boat in six days, and on the seventh, He sent the XO to inspect the work.
Junior officers caught the worst of it. A seaman's mistakes could still be written off to youth, natural stupidity, and the inevitable limitations of the conscript pool. A Chief was forgiven a lot for his time in service, his gray hair, and his ability to fix gear that industry didn't even manufacture anymore. But a lieutenant had voluntarily entered the academy, studied for five years, received his shoulder boards, and therefore consciously forfeited the right to be a du***ss. The narrator caught it double exactly because the XO saw him as one of his own—a missile tech—and gave no discounts for age or inexperience. Sometimes it was useful. Sometimes it was unfair. Sometimes it was just humiliating. Behind his back, the junior officers called him names that made the XO's perfectly decent actual last name look almost affectionate in comparison. He himself, it seemed, understood how he was viewed and had no intention of fixing it.
With the Skipper, everything looked completely different. The Skipper, a Captain, was a calm man with the kind of power that doesn't need to prove its existence every day. He could walk into the control room, look at the gauges, and say: "I don't really like the look of the tertiary loop," and a few minutes later everyone who could possibly dislike it in a professional capacity would be gathered around the tertiary loop. The XO beside him became emphatically strictly-by-the-book: "Aye, Skipper." "Yes, sir." "It will be done."
When the Skipper told him in front of everyone: "Stop busting their balls, they’ve been on their feet for two days straight," the XO would snap to attention and reply: "Aye, Skipper. Stop busting their balls." And he would say it with such a serious face that even the greenest lieutenant understood: this was theater. Between the Skipper and the XO played out an old game of authority and subordination, understood by both of them. The crew read that. What the crew didn't read was that the XO was playing exactly the same game for them, too. The role was simply memorized flawlessly.
The Lieutenant got to see his other life the year their crew was being decommissioned and disbanded. The early nineties in general were a time when the verb "disband" was heard almost more often than the word "serve." Boats were pulled from service, units were downsized, officers were dragged off to new billets, and the country they had sworn an oath to was itself starting to resemble a ship where orchestras were still playing on the upper deck while down below someone was busy cutting the bulkheads with a torch.
They offered the young officer a chance to stay. They considered him promising: he was good with the hardware, understood electronics, had a working brain, and his subordinates respected him. The Skipper talked to him. The zampolit [political officer] also had the mandatory chat. Then both of them apparently decided that the final argument should be the XO, and asked him to talk to the man the Navy didn't want to lose.
The XO called him in after hours.
"Planning to leave?"
"Yes, sir."
"Yes, or 'Yes, sir'?"
The Lieutenant paused.
"Yes."
The XO looked at him for a few seconds, and the lieutenant mentally braced himself for the usual ass-chewing: the oath, duty, the Motherland invested money in you, an officer has no right. But the XO only asked:
"Are you busy tonight?"
"No."
"Then come over to my place. I don't want to talk here. And you don't have to wear your uniform. The wife will force you to eat anyway."
Refusing the XO was harder than resigning from the Navy, so that evening the young officer showed up. The XO lived in a typical garrison apartment block—just like the rest of them: a narrow stairwell, the smell of boiled potatoes and wet kids' clothes, a sled under the landing, someone's boots outside a door, a radiator that produced heat only on paper. The XO's wife opened the door, a small woman in a house cardigan. Seeing the guest, she smiled:
"Ah, it's you. Come in. He said you'd drop by."
The mere fact that the XO spoke of his subordinates' existence at home without using profanity seemed highly suspicious. The host himself was sitting in the kitchen in sweatpants and an ironed t-shirt. Without his tunic, his belt, and the control room, he unexpectedly turned out to be just a forty-something guy with a tired face. He stood up, helped his wife clear the extra dishes from the table, kissed her somewhere near the temple, and said:
"Just don't throw us a banquet. We need to talk."
"I know you guys. 'Talking' with you always ends in starvation by midnight."
She set down a skillet with fried potatoes, some herring, and a kettle. The Lieutenant, out of habit, declined the food.
"You're not giving a brief," the XO said. "Eat. Otherwise tomorrow you'll start telling people I starve my officers, too."
And then the truly unbelievable started. The XO didn't ask about the service. How was the wife? How was the kid? Did he stop getting sick after that bout of bronchitis? Was there still a draft from the window in their room? Where did his wife plan to work if they left the North? Did they have anywhere to go? Who would help them out at first? He remembered things the Lieutenant had once mentioned in passing and had long since forgotten he’d even said. On the boat, this man could publicly inform him in the morning that with his level of organizational skills, it was dangerous to let him manage a public restroom, and then in the evening, he was asking if they had moved the crib away from the cold wall. The young officer sat there feeling a strange sensation: as if he had been lied to for months, only he couldn't figure out where exactly—on the boat, or here.
When they got to the main point, the XO immediately laid out the tactical situation.
"The Skipper and the zampolit asked me to talk to you. They don't want to lose you. Neither do I. You could make a good officer. Not a 'decent' one, a good one. Now tell me why you're leaving."
The Lieutenant began to explain. The crew was being disbanded. The new duty station was unknown. The wife was tired of the garrison life. The kid was growing. The money was okay, but they’d started delaying the paychecks. But it wasn't even about the money. He increasingly caught himself thinking that he no longer understood where the service was heading, or whether the straight line upon which careers were built just yesterday even existed anymore: Ensign, Lieutenant (j.g.), division officer, department head... The rungs were still there, but it felt like someone had carried the ladder out of the house.
The XO listened calmly. He didn't interrupt, didn't argue. Then he poured himself some tea and said:
"Alright. So what do you want from me? For me to talk you out of it?"
"I don't know. You're the one who called me in to talk... But since the conversation went there, I'd ask for your advice, I guess."
"It's a bad time for advice. Today I'll tell you: stay, the Navy is eternal. And tomorrow we wake up—and half the fleet is gone. Hell, not just the fleet... Sometimes I get the feeling that they aren't just decommissioning our crew, they're scrapping the whole damn country. They put the Union into the shipyards and they're cutting it up into sections. Let's just hope they don't cut the reactor compartments out of our boats cleaner than they cut the republics out of the country."
He chuckled, but there was no joy in it. Then he turned serious.
"If you want to serve—stay. I'll help you any way I can. You've got room to grow. You understand the gear, you handle the men fine, your head isn't just for decoration. But if you don't want to—leave. Just don't leave out of resentment. And don't stay out of fear. The dumbest thing you can do is live someone else's life just because you were too scared to change course when you had the chance."
"Would you leave?"
The XO thought about it.
"Me? No. It's too late for me. And besides this nuthouse, I probably don't know how to do anything else anymore."
From the other room, his wife chimed in:
"Don't be so modest. You don't know how to give orders at home either."
The XO smiled. He didn't smirk, like on the boat, but actually smiled.
"See? An objective performance eval from my duty station."
At that moment, his youngest appeared in the kitchen—a kid about twelve with a notebook in his hand. His wife immediately remembered the thing she had apparently been saving all evening for her husband's return.
"Oh, by the way. Have a word with the heir. An 'F' again."
The XO looked at his son.
"For what?"
"Math."
"Be specific."
"Decimal fractions."
"Fractions... and decimals at that—serious business. Nations have fallen apart over less. Bring it here."
He opened the notebook and didn't raise his voice once. Didn't ask why he hadn't studied. Didn't inquire what his son planned to become in life with grades like that.
"Look. This here is one box. Whole. One. Got it? Like one boat."
"Got it."
"Now I divide it into ten equal parts. One piece, how much of the box is that?"
"One tenth."
"Right. And so you don't have to write 'one tenth' every time, smart people invented the decimal point. They write it like this: 0.1. Read as: zero wholes and one tenth. The decimal point is like a bulkhead. To the left of it is the whole, to the right is what they sawed off of it."
He pushed one piece aside.
"This is 0.1. And this?"
He pushed four more aside.
"Five pieces. 0.5. Half. Your favorite fifty kopecks. You had a ruble, 50 kopecks is 0.5 of a ruble. Got it?"
"Yeah."
"Now watch this magic trick. What happens if you add 0.5 to another 0.5?"
"One."
"Exactly. 0.5 plus 0.5 is 1.0. One whole box. Half plus half is always a whole. Whether it's sugar, money, or torpedoes. We’ve got ten fish on the racks. One fish is 0.1 of a loadout. Five fish is 0.5. And ten fish is 1.0. A full tactical loadout. Only you can't have zero-point-five of a person, clear?"
"Clear."
"And which is bigger, 0.2 or 0.8?"
"0.8."
"Why?"
"There are more pieces there."
"Good job. Not hopeless after all. And the teacher gives you an 'F'. Who are we supposed to believe?"
The kid laughed. A few minutes later they were dividing sugar, apples, some hypothetical money, and, naturally, torpedoes. For some reason, the XO didn't bring missiles into his home schooling. Then the son asked:
"Dad, what if I get another 'F'?"
"You'll fix it."
"And if I don't fix it?"
"So what?"
His wife appeared in the doorway.
"See! That's why he isn't afraid of you. If only for once you talked to him the way you talk to your lieutenants."
The XO put his palm on the back of his son's head.
"Seryozha, an 'F' is not a hull breach. No one's going to drown from it. If you want to go to college later—you'll have to study. If you don't—don't go. You'll be a carpenter, a driver, a janitor. A sailor, if you absolutely can't think of anything else. Honest work doesn't shame a man. Just decide for yourself what you want, and do it right. And the main thing—stay a decent human being. The rest can either be fixed or survived."
"What about a 'C'?"
"A 'C' even more so. Half the country was built on 'C's, son."
His wife shook her head.
"If only you talked to your officers like that."
The XO looked at the guest, then at his son.
"Seryozha doesn't have a nuclear reactor right behind his back."
"Your lieutenants have something more important than reactors too... for example—families..."
He didn't answer right away.
"I know."
That short "I know" is probably what the Lieutenant remembered best of all. Not because the XO suddenly became a kind boss after that. The next morning he walked into the control room as the exact same man the crew had known for years. Found an error in the log, ripped into the OOD, crawled through the compartments, dug up something that wasn't supposed to be there, and then got to the Fire Control Officer. The Lieutenant once again listened to a lecture on how computing equipment does not relieve an officer of the obligation to think with his own head. No miraculous transformation occurred. It’s just that now, one man on the boat knew: this harshness was not the entirety of the XO's personality. Perhaps it wasn't even the main part of it. It was a tool that he, for some reason, considered absolutely necessary on a ship where a mistake could genuinely cost far more than someone's ruined mood.
The Lieutenant made his decision anyway. He left the Navy. The XO didn't try to talk him out of it anymore. When he ran into him in the headquarters corridor some time later, he only asked:
"Is your decision final?"
"Yes."
"Then don't look back. If you look back after every course change, you won't get very far."
Life then sorted things out rather ironically. The Navy lost a promising officer, but the man didn't go under. His technical education, his habit of understanding the hardware, and his distrust of the phrase "the computer calculated it that way" turned out to be in demand on the beach [on shore], too. Years later, that same Lieutenant became a lead electronics engineer at an IT company involved in developing and programming equipment—what they now call hardware. He no longer had reactors behind his back, nor missile flight assignments, but the habit of double-checking a digit before saying "the system spit it out" stayed with him for the rest of his life.
Many years later, he wrote to me not about the boat, not about the missiles, and not even about why he left. He told me about the XO he had once almost hated. An annoying thing happens as you get older: people who, when you were twenty, were so easily sorted into "good" and "bad," suddenly stop fitting into those two boxes. Understanding doesn't mean forgiving—some of those ass-chewings from that XO were unjust, some words humiliating, and adult wisdom isn't obligated to retroactively turn being an as***le into a pedagogical method. But a man is rarely equal to his worst role. On the boat, that XO considered it his duty to be the one they feared; at home—the one you felt safe beside. The crew saw his first life and took it as his only one. His family lived with the second and, quite possibly, didn't fully comprehend the first. And he himself walked between them every day—from the kitchen table to the conn and back—and, maybe, had long since stopped asking which of the two faces was real. Because, most likely, both were. It's just that one of his watches began the moment he stepped over the hatch coaming of the boat, and the other—when he opened the door to his own apartment. And it remains unknown which of the two was harder.