09/04/2026
John Curtiss Underwood (b. March 14, 1809; d. Dec. 7, 1873) was a lawyer and outspoken antislavery activist. In the 1850s, he and his family lived in Clarke County, Va. By the end of 1856, his neighbors had so often threatened his safety that Underwood left and moved his family to New York. His written account of his exile was published in The New York Times on Jan. 6, 1857.
President Lincoln appointed Underwood a federal judge for Virginia’s eastern district in 1863. He was reassigned to the United States District Court for the District of Virginia on June 11, 1864. In this position, Judge Underwood presided over the grand jury that indicted Confederate president Jefferson Davis for treason in May 1866.
Judge Underwood continued his highly critical and public remarks against former Confederates and their sympathizers in favor of African American suffrage.
He was elected president of the Virginia Constitutional Convention of 1867-68, and its “The Underwood Constitution” granted Black men the right to vote, established a system of free public schools, and secured other democratic reforms.
The long letter John Underwood wrote to The New York Times after leaving Clarke County includes this passage:
“We were sad at seeing our household goods scattered around us; for, though in form a voluntary sale, it was, in fact, a forced sale … forced upon us by the oppression of proud and cruel men, who neither feared God nor regarded humanity. Our little children were grieving over the sale of the horses and colts, cows and calves, pet lambs and playthings, which they had been accustomed to call their own, and to which they had become attached, as farmers’ children often are. To increase the gloom and desolation caused by this general breaking up and scattering of those old and familiar associations and objects to which our hearts fondly clung, our kind neighbor, Mr. Feltner, called late in the afternoon with a message from another friendly neighbor, that we must immediately prepare for the reception of a Committee of Vigilance, which was coming on with the most hostile intentions. This seemed to explain the mistake published in the papers respecting the day of the sale. And now came trouble to my wife and her female friends, who urged me to leave the house and them, as they supposed the mob would be appeased if made certain of my absence.”
Read the full text of John C. Underwood’s letter to The New York Times at https://encyclopediavirginia.org/primary-documents/letter-from-john-c-underwood-in-the-new-york-times-january-6-1857/
Read more about Mr. Underwood at https://encyclopediavirginia.org/entries/underwood-john-c-1809-1873/