03/06/2026
The Tragic Origin of the "No White" Rule: The Story of the Knight Commander ⛵️🤍
Did you know this taboo is rooted in one of the most heartbreaking tragedies in our village history?
The origin of this fear is connected to the coble Knight Commander (WY99). While most Staithes boats used sails treated with bark to turn them a traditional rusty red or brown, the Knight Commander was readily recognisable because she was the only one in the fleet with unbarked, white sails.
On the night of Saturday, 30th September 1899, the Unthank family—70-year-old Francis and his two sons, William and Francis Jr.—were returning from Hartlepool after landing a massive catch of herring. Old Francis was so heartened by their success that he told a fellow fisherman on the quay, "This will give us bread for the winter."
However, as they approached Staithes, a fierce storm overset the coble, and all three men were drowned in sight of the village. The tragedy was made even more bitter because Francis Jr. was due to be married the following Monday. In the Unthank home, the white tablecloth that had been spread for the wedding feast was instead used as a shroud for the father’s body, which was the only one recovered from the shore initially.
It was months before a sea-booted leg washed up, identified as one of the lost brothers by his initials stitched in red wool into the stocking—a specific Staithes custom used to identify those lost at sea. From that day on, white became a colour of foreboding for the Staithes fishing fleet, forever associated with the loss of the Knight Commander.
So, if you’re planning a trip out on the water, leave your white mugs at home and keep the "no white" rule in mind!