09/22/2023
My 2024 updated “not in the HOF” All-Star Teams. ************
Team 1
C: Thurman Munson *
1B: Will Clark *
2B: Pete Rose *
3B: Ken Boyer *
SS: Álex Rodríguez
OF: Dale Murphy *
OF: Andruw Jones
OF: Shoeless Joe Jackson *
DH: Mark McGwire *
RHP: Roger Clemens *
LHP: Mickey Lolich *
RP: Smoky Joe Wood *
Closer: Billy Wagner
Manager: Lou Piniella
Team 2
C: Bill Freehan *
1B: Don Mattingly *
2B: Lou Whitaker *
3B: Bill Dahlen *
SS: Dave Concepción *
OF: Roger Maris *
OF: Barry Bonds *
OF: Lefty O'DouL *
DH: Gary Sheffield
RHP: Curt Schilling *
LHP: Tommy John *
RP: Bucky Walters *
Closer: Dan Quisenberry *
Manager: Bruce Bochy
Team 3
C: Lance Parrish *
1B: Todd Helton
2B: Bobby Grich *
3B: Cecil Travis *
SS: Nomar Garciaparra *
OF: Sammy Sosa *
OF: Dwight Evans *
OF: Pete Browning *
DH: Manny Ramírez
RHP: Luis Tiant *
LHP: Hippo Vaughn *
RP: Wes Ferrell *
Closer: John Franco *
Manager: Dusty Baker
Team 4
C: Rudy York *
1B: Steve Garvey *
2B: Jeff Kent
3B: Graig Nettles *
SS: Maury Wills *
OF: Dave Parker *
OF: Jim Edmonds *
OF: Dick Allen *
DH: José Canseco *
RHP: Orel Hershiser *
LHP: Billy Pierce *
RP: Babe Adams *
Closer: Carl Mays *
Manager: Gene Mauch
Team 5
C: Elston Howard *
1B: Keith Hernandez *
2B: George “Tubby” Scales *
3B: Darrell Evans *
SS: Marty Marion *
OF: Vada Pinson *
OF: Kenny Lofton *
OF: “Indian” Bob Johnson *
DH: Rusty Staub *
RHP: David Cone *
LHP: Wilbur Cooper *
RP: Denny McLain *
Closer: Don Newcombe *
Manager: Buck Showalter
Team 6
C: Smoky Burgess *
1B: Rafael Palmeiro *
2B: Riggs Stephenson *
3B: Harvey Kuenn *
SS: Omar Vizquel
OF: Al Oliver *
OF: Fred Lynn *
OF: Rocky Colavito *
DH: Albert Belle *
RHP: Johnny Sain *
LHP: Vida Blue *
RP: Bob Caruthers *
Closer: Red Ames *
Manager: Terry Francona
Team 7
C: Brian McCann
1B: Cecil Cooper *
2B: Buddy Myer *
3B: Bill Madlock *
SS: Vern Stephens *
OF: Babe Herman *
OF: Bo Jackson *
OF: Dixie Walker *
DH: Carlos Delgado *
RHP: Dwight Gooden *
LHP: Johan Santana
RP: Jim McCormick *
Closer: Sparky Lyle *
Manager: Ralph Houk
Team 8
C: Walker Cooper *
1B: Mark Grace *
2B: Alfonso Soriano *
3B: Matt Williams *
SS: Stan Hack *
OF: Reggie Smith *
OF: Carlos Beltran
OF: Tip O’Neill *
DH: Ted Kluszewski *
RHP: Tony Mullane *
LHP: David Wells *
RP: Bret Saberhagen *
Closer: Tug McGraw *
Manager: Dick Howser
Team 9
C: Bob Boone *
1B: Norm Cash *
2B: Dustin Pedroia
3B: Bob Elliott *
SS: Bert Campaneris *
OF: Kirk Gibson *
OF: Willie McGee *
OF: Sherry Magee *
DH: Andrés Galarraga *
RHP: Kevin Brown *
LHP: Ron Guidry *
RP: Eddie Cicotte *
Closer: Jeff Reardon *
Manager: Billy Martin
Team 10
C: Jason Varitek *
1B: Stuffy McInnis *
2B: Willie Randolph *
3B: Buddy Bell *
SS: Alvin Dark *
OF: Curt Flood *
OF: George Van Haltren *
OF: Juan González *
DH: Frank Howard *
RHP: Dennís Martínez *
LHP: Andy Pettitte *
RP: Allie Reynolds *
Closer: J.R. Richard *
Manager: Brian Snitker
Team 11
C: Benito Santiago *
1B: Mickey Vernon *
2B: Newt Allen *
3B: Ron Cey *
SS: Dick Groat *
OF: Darryl Strawberry *
OF: Johnny Damon
OF: Vic Harris *
DH: Jason Giambi *
RHP: Lew Burdette *
LHP: Fernando Valenzuela *
RP: Doc White *
Closer: Joe Nathan
Manager: Joe Maddon
Team 12
C: Sherm Lollar *
1B: Bill Buckner *
2B: Pepper Martin *
3B: Bobby Bonilla *
SS: Tony Fernández *
OF: Dom DiMaggio *
OF: Jimmy Ryan *
OF: Joe Carter *
DH: Mo Vaughn *
RHP: Tim Hudson
LHP: Jerry Koosman *
RP: Silver King *
Closer: Rob Nen *
Manager: Chuck Tanner
Team 13
C: Quincy Trouppe *
1B: John Olerud *
2B: Ross Barnes *
3B: Terry Pendleton *
SS: Jack Glasscock *
OF: Cy Williams *
OF: Torii Hunter *
OF: Bobby Thomson *
DH: Lance Berkman *
RHP: Paul Derringer *
LHP: Mark Buehrle
RP: Dave Stieb *
Closer: Virgil Trucks *
Manager: Davey Johnson
Team 14
C: Sandy Alomar Jr. *
1B: Jake Daubert *
2B: Chase Utley
3B: Lave Cross *
SS: Michael Young
OF: Dale Mitchell *
OF: Bernie Williams *
OF: Magglio Ordóñez *
DH: “King Kong” Keller *
RHP: Tommy Bond *
LHP: Frank Tanana *
RP: Milt Pappas *
Closer: Francisco Rodriguez
Manager: Mike Scioscia
Team 15
C: Spud Davis *
1B: Mark Teixeira *
2B: Heinie Groh *
3B: Sal Bando *
SS: Jimmy Rollins
OF: César Cedeño *
OF: Wally Berger *
OF: Wild Bill Wright *
DH: Adam Dunn *
RHP: “Cannonball” Dick Redding *
LHP: Jamie Moyer *
RP: Mel Harder *
Closer: Charlie Root *
Manager: Bob Melvin
Team 16
C: Wally Schang *
1B: Paul Konerko
2B: Frank White *
3B: Tim Wallach *
SS: Johnny Pesky *
OF: David Justice *
OF: Wally Moses *
OF: George Foster *
DH: Julio Franco *
RHP: Kerry Wood *
LHP: Jimmy Key *
RP: Tommy Bridges *
Closer: Roy Face *
Manager: Ned Yost
Team 17
C: Tony Pena *
1B: Joe Adcock *
2B: Paul Hines *
3B: David Wright
SS: Dobie Moore *
OF: Paul O’Neill *
OF: Bingo DeMoss *
OF: Marquis Grissom *
DH: Chili Davis *
RHP: Will White *
LHP: Cliff Lee *
RP: Ed Reulbach *
Closer: John Wetteland *
Manager: Jimmy D***s
Team 18
C: Javy Lopez *
1B: Dave Orr *
2B: Chuck Knoblauch *
3B: Al Rosen *
SS: Miguel Tejada *
OF: Josh Hamilton
OF: Doc Cramer *
OF: Moises Alou *
DH: Jack Clark *
RHP: Roy Oswalt *
LHP: Jesse Tannehill *
RP: Freddie Fitzsimmons *
Closer: Steve Bedrosian *
Manager: Roger Craig
Team 19
C: Mickey Tettleton *
1B: Sean Casey *
2B: Tony Phillips *
3B: Oliver Marcelle *
SS: Art Fletcher *
OF: Luis Gonzalez *
OF: Willie Wilson *
OF: Bibb Falk *
DH: Cecil Fielder *
RHP: Dolf Luque *
LHP: Kenny Rogers *
RP: Lon Warneke *
Closer: Randy Myers *
Manager: Danny Murtaugh
Team 20
C: “Double Duty” Radcliffe *
1B: Ryan Howard
2B: Brett Boone *
3B: Ken Caminiti *
SS: Dick Lundy *
OF: J.D. Drew *
OF: Spottswood Poles *
OF: Ken Williams *
DH: Prince Fielder
RHP: Jack Coombs *
LHP: Sam McDowell *
RP: Noodles Hahn *
Closer: Al Hrabosky *
Manager: Mike Hargrove
Team 21
C: Jorge Posada *
1B: Charlie Grimm *
2B: Steve Sax *
3B: Bob Meusel *
SS: Troy Tulowitzki *
OF: George Bell *
OF: Steve Finley *
OF: Irish Meusel *
DH: Don Baylor *
RHP: Rick Reuschel *
LHP: Ed Morris *
RP: Jake Peavy *
Closer: Tom Henke *
Manager: Charlie Manuel
Team 22
C: Jason Kendall *
1B: Hal Chase *
2B: Dick Bartell *
3B: Bucky Dent *
SS: Herb Souell *
OF: José Cruz *
OF: Rick Monday *
OF: Dante Bichette *
DH: Boog Powell *
RHP: Josh Beckett *
LHP: Frank Viola *
RP: Don Larsen *
Closer: Urban Shocker *
Manager: Joe Girardi
Team 23
C: Ray Fosse *
1B: John Kruk *
2B: Lonny Frey *
3B: Vinny Castilla *
SS: Andy Pafko *
OF: Jake Stenzel *
OF: Brett Butler *
OF: Hideki Matsui *
DH: Matt Holliday
RHP: Bob Welch *
LHP: Chuck Finley *
RP: Charlie Hough *
Closer: Eric Gagne *
Manager: Felipe Alou
Team 24
C: Charles Johnson *
1B: Ed Konetchy *
2B: Carlos Baerga *
3B: Ryan Zimmerman
SS: Edgar Rentería *
OF: Jim Wynn *
OF: Eric Davis *
OF: Bing Miller *
DH: Bobby Bonds *
RHP: Rick Sutcliffe *
LHP: Nip Winters *
RP: Bob Friend *
Closer: Gene Garber *
Manager: Art Howe
Team 25
C: Gene Tenance *
1B: Shawn Green *
2B: Davey Lopes *
3B: Gary Gaetti *
SS: Jay Bell *
OF: Jay Bruce *
OF: Willie Davis *
OF: Ron Gant *
DH: Bob Fothergill *
RHP: Charlie Buffinton *
LHP: Al Leiter *
RP: Phil Douglas *
Closer: Dave Stewart *
Manager: Cito Gaston
* = No longer on BBWAA ballot; player must be considered by HOF Veterans Committees.
Honorable mentions:
Position Players -- Heavy Johnson, Hurley McNair, Jim West, Jerry Benjamin, Bruce Petway, Sam Jethroe, John Beckwith, Sammy Hughes, “Gentleman Dave” Malarcher, Homerun Johnson, Lennie Pearson, Sandy Thompson, Roy Parnell, Pat Patterson, Wade Johnston, George Carr, Fats Jenkins, Marvin Williams, Pepper Bassett, Charlie Blackwell, Jim Gilliam, Mike Donlin, Tommy Leach, Joe Harris, Red Rolfe, Bug Holliday, Babe Phelps, Clyde Milan, Bill Lange, Herman Long, Happy Felsch, Charlie Keller, Duffy Lewis, Jimmie Wilson, Glenn Wright, Lew Fonseca, Johnny Kling, Eddie Stanky, Jack Fournier, Herman Long, Bob O'Farrell, Barney McCosky, Jimmy D***s, Joe Judge, Mickey Owen, Steve O’Neill, Hal Trosky, Harlond Clift, Eddie Yost, Fred Tenney, Solly Hemus, Carl Furillo, Wally Pipp, Tim McCarver, Ben Chapman, Ray Chapman, Rip Radcliff, Tommy Henrich, Toby Harrah, Tony Conigliaro, Jim Sundberg, Manny Sanguillén, Rick Dempsey, Rico Carty, Ralph Garr, Dave Kingman, Hal McRae, Roy Sievers, Vic Wertz, Greg Luzinski, Matty Alou, Bob Horner, Glenn Hubbard, Bruce Benedict, Glenn Davis, Darrell Porter, Willie Horton, Mark Belanger, Lee May, Larry Bowa, George Hendrick, George Scott, Chet Lemon, Ken Singleton, Terry Steinbach, Garry Templaton, Bo Díaz, Carney Lansford, Mike Greenwell, Tommy Herr, Kevin Mitchell, Robin Ventura, Wally Joyner, Walt Weiss, Harold Reynolds, Pedro Guerrero, Vince Coleman, Rubén Sierra, Ray Knight, Tom Brunansky, Matt Stairs, B.J. Surhoff, Devon White, Eric Karros, Ellis Burks, Jay Buhner, Reggie Sanders, J.T. Snow, Brian Giles, Andy Van Slyke, Lenny Dykstra, Chris Sabo, Mike Lowell, Jeff Conine, Deion Sanders, Justin Morneau, Jermaine Dye, Greg Vaughn, Travis Fryman, Troy Glaus, Ryan Klesko, Tim Salmon, Adrián González, Tino Martinez, Derek Bell, Carlos Lee, Bobby Abreu, Jeromy Burnitz, Pat Burrell, Mark Reynolds, Garret Anderson, A.J. Pierzynsk, Matt Kemp, Adam Jones, Ryan Braun, Hanley Ramírez, Nick Markakis, Ian Kinsler, Jose Bautista, Travis Hafner, Jacoby Ellsbury, Ian Kinsler, Victor Martinez, Edwin Encarnacion, Raul Ibanez, Pablo Sandoval, Todd Frazier, Yoenis Céspedes, Yasiel Puig, Russell Martin
Pitchers -- John Donaldson, William Bell Sr., Max Manning, Dave Barnhill, Bob Shawkey, Larry Jackson, Matt Kilroy, Art Nehf, Eddie Rommel, Theo Breitenstein, Frank Killen, Bill Sherdel, Dutch Leonard, Curt Simmons, Red Russell, Dick Radatz, Dock Ellis, Jim Perry, Jerry Reuss, Joe Niekro, Mark Fidrych, Johnny Podres, Rick Rhoden, Dave Righetti, Mike Scott, Mark Langston, Jim Abbott, Dan Plesac, John Tudor, Todd Worrell, Doug Drabeck, Teddy Higuera, Rod Beck, Jack McDowell, Ramón Martínez, Hideo Nomo, Mike Hampton, Chris Carpenter, A.J. Burnett, Jason Schmidt, Robb Nen, Ryan Dempster, Tim Lincecum, Jonathan Papelbon, Jose Fernandez,
Tim Wakefield
Recently retired & more likely to be inducted on BBWAA Ballot — Ichiro Suzuki, Albert Pujols, Buster Posey, Yadier Molina, Robinson Cano, C.C. Sabathia, Cole Hamels, Felix Hernandez, Bartolo Colon