03/18/2026
This week’s Wednesday takes a look back at the Edgar family and their contributions to the history of Iron County. The Edgar family came to Iron County from Tipton, Iowa in 1866. Three generations of Edgars, spanning over 100 years, practiced law in Iron County. Another one of the descendants was an insurance company executive and very active in the local community.
William R. Edgar II, born September 17, 1851, in Tipton, Cedar County, Iowa, was the son of William R. and Rebecca G. (Tichenor) Edgar and descended from Scottish and Revolutionary War lineage. After attending public school in Ironton, he spent two years at the United States Military Academy at West Point before completing his law degree at Washington University in St. Louis in 1875. The following year, he registered to practice law at the Iron County Courthouse and soon partnered for a time with J. W. Emerson. In 1878, Edgar was elected prosecuting attorney of Iron County, a position he would hold through four consecutive reelections. To supplement his legal income—and to meet the community’s need for a mathematics instructor—he also taught for four years at Arcadia College in Arcadia, Missouri. Among his students was Sara Pressia Whitworth, daughter of Isaac G. and Nancy B. (White) Whitworth. William and Sara married on October 5, 1880, and made their home in his father’s house on Russellville Road. The couple raised five children—Maude, William R. III, Mary, James, and Robert L.—and later built a Queen Anne–style residence on East Reynolds Street in Ironton. The home remained in the family for generations, last occupied by their grandson, William R. Edgar IV, before being razed following his death in 1998.
William R. Edgar II’s public life extended far beyond his long service as prosecuting attorney. He served as Receiver of the U.S. Land Office in Ironton, chaired the local Democratic Committee, sat on the State Democratic Committee, served as Mayor of Ironton, and acted as a presidential elector. Within the Masonic fraternity, he was a member and past master of Star of the West Lodge No. 133, A.F. & A.M., and High Priest of Midian Chapter No. 71. He and his wife, Sara Pressia, were also charter members of Ironton Chapter No. 349, Order of the Eastern Star. Around 1894, Edgar joined the board of directors of the Iron County Bank and later served for many years as its president. In partnership with his son, William R. Edgar III, he handled numerous cases in the Iron County Circuit Court. Their firm, Edgar & Edgar, represented clients such as the Sligo Furnace Company, the Ironton Academy of Music, and the Gay and Kendall Mercantile Company. In 1904, the two established the Iron County Abstract Company.
William R. Edgar II died in Ironton on September 26, 1921, and was buried in the Masonic Cemetery in Arcadia. A memorial service honoring his life and service was held at the Iron County Courthouse on October 3, 1921. Sara Pressia, who had devoted herself to her family and was an early member of the Fort Hill Methodist Episcopal Church, later moved to St. Louis to live with their youngest son, Robert. She died on August 23, 1939, and was laid to rest beside her husband in the Masonic Cemetery in Arcadia.
William R. Edgar III , known as Will, was born on May 24, 1885, in Ironton, Missouri, and graduated from Ironton High School in 1901. In the early years of the new century, he moved to St. Louis, where he worked as a clerk in the legal department of the Missouri Pacific Railroad while attending the Benton School of Law at night. He earned his law degree in 1910 and was licensed to practice shortly thereafter.
He returned to Ironton in 1911 and married Mary A. Roehry, daughter of Anton and Emma (Mark) Roehry. Born in Ironton on November 17, 1886, Mary had been educated at the Ursuline Academy in Arcadia and was an accomplished pianist who served for many years as organist at Saint Paul’s Episcopal Church. Although Will had originally intended to build his legal career in St. Louis, he came home to join his father’s practice when William R. Edgar II fell ill.
Will and Mary first lived in the Edgar home on Russellville Road before building their own house at 116 East Dent Street. In the mid 1920s, they moved into his parents’ residence on East Reynolds Street. Will served as Prosecuting Attorney of Iron County for about eight years, later becoming president of the Iron County Security Bank during the 1930s. In 1938, he served an eight month term as Circuit Judge and also spent many years as Ironton’s City Attorney.
Throughout the 1920s and 1930s, Will managed a substantial caseload on his own. In 1937, his son, William R. Edgar IV, joined the practice, and the firm once again operated under the name Edgar & Edgar. The Iron County Abstract Company, founded by his father and grandfather, continued its work as well.
Will was active in civic and fraternal life, maintaining more than fifty years of membership in the Masonic organization and long involvement with the Rotary Club. He chaired the fundraising campaign that helped save St. Mary’s of the Ozarks Hospital. In 1967, he began serving as probate and magistrate judge. He died on August 24, 1967, and was buried in the Masonic Cemetery in Arcadia. Mary Edgar died on April 1, 1975, and was laid to rest beside him.
William R. Edgar IV, the son and only child of William R. Edgar III, and Mary Edgar was born on August 25, 1912. Known as Bill, he graduated from Ironton High School in 1930 and then attended Washington University and then Washington University Law School. After passing his bar exam in 1937, Bill joined his father in the Edgar & Edgar Law Firm and the Iron County Abstract Company. Bill was drafted into the U.S. Army in World War II and served in Europe. He returned to Ironton in 1946 but was called back to active duty as a reservist from 1950 to 1952, during the Korean War, and served in Germany during this time. He again returned to Ironton after his service, taking over the law practice and abstract company upon the death of his father in 1967. Bill died on September 30, 1998, and was buried in the Edgar family plot in the Masonic Cemetery. Bill’s legacy lives on today through the William Edgar Charitable Foundation that was created after his death. Each year, the foundation awards scholarships to graduates of the Arcadia Valley High School and provides grant funding to non-profit organizations throughout Iron County.
Another prominent member of the Edgar family was Robert “Bob” L. Edgar. Bob was the youngest brother of William R. Edgar III and was born on April 20, 1900. Bob graduated from Ironton High School in 1918. He attended the United States Military Academy for one year and later graduated from Washington University Law School in 1923. After his graduation he became affiliated with Lon W. Harlow & Co, of St, Louis. The company dealt in all types of insurance, except for life insurance, and also dealt in surety bonds. After Lon Harlow’s death, Bob became the sole owner of the company. Bob married Isabelle Baker on December 4, 1937. They were the parents of two sons, Robert L. Edgar Jr. (1941 – 2004) and James Douglas Edgar (1943 – 1988). Besides being an insurance company executive, Bob was also devoted to the Arcadia Valley. He served as the secretary to both the Arcadia Valley Chamber of Commerce and the Arcadia Valley Alumni Association. He served on the executive committee for the Iron County Centennial Association in 1957 and served as the Chairman of the Battle of Pilot K**b Centennial observance in 1964. Bob was also involved in the Boy Scouts and earned the Silver Beaver Award, scouting’s highest honor for an adult volunteer. Bob died after a short illness on May 2, 1968. He was remembered in his obituary as, “The best friend the Arcadia Valley ever had.” Bob was buried in the Masonic Cemetery in Arcadia.
Most of the information for this week’s column came from the entries for the Edgar family members in the Family History section of, “Past and Present, A History of Iron County, Missouri 1857 -1994, Vol I”. This book is available for purchase at our museum or on-line through our website at https://ironcountyhistory.org/store.php?cid=2&sid=2 . Until next week…