04/16/2026
đ”Coleman County Museum Presentsđ”
The Legacy of the Nance Saddle Shop
Long before paved roads and modern storefronts, the heartbeat of early Coleman County could be heard in the steady rhythm of hammers, leather tools, and craftsmanship that defined daily life on the frontier. Among those who helped shape this rugged and determined community was the Nance Saddle Shop â a cornerstone of both necessity and pride in 19th-century Coleman.
In the late 1800s, when ranching was not just an occupation but a way of life, a well-made saddle was essential. The Nance Saddle Shop served cowboys, ranchers, and travelers alike, producing durable, hand-tooled saddles and tack that could withstand the harsh demands of West Texas terrain. Each piece was crafted with precision, reflecting both function and artistry â a true testament to frontier ingenuity.
One of the most memorable parts of the shop was its âfitting modelâ â an old gray horse that patiently stood as saddles were shaped and tested. This trusted model played a quiet but important role in the process, helping ensure each saddle was properly balanced and ready for the long rides ahead. For many in the community, the sight of that steady gray horse became just as familiar as the craftsmen themselves.
By the early 20th century, the business had grown alongside the town. In 1929, J. H. Nance and Son was located at 105 South Commercial Avenue and was owned by James H. and Bennett A. Nance. Their shop had expanded well beyond saddles, serving as both manufacturer and dealer of saddles, harness, collars, bridles, and a complete line of leather goods. They also offered shoe repairing, cowboy boots, automobile tops and seat covers, and awnings â adapting to the changing needs of a community transitioning from horseback to motor travel. Their telephone number? Simply **3** â a small detail that speaks volumes about just how early and established this business was in Coleman. *(Coleman City Directory, 1929 â Hudspeth)*
Additional insight into the family behind the business comes from "The J. H. Nance Family" by Freda Hindman McGuckin, published in *A History of Coleman County and Its People (1985)*. James Howard Nance was born February 28, 1864, in Nacogdoches County, Texas, with family roots tracing back to Tennessee. He arrived in Coleman on January 13, 1900, bringing with him the skill of saddle making that would define his lifeâs work.
J. H.âs story is also one of family and perseverance. His first wife, Emma, passed away in 1899, leaving him with their young son, Bennett A. Nance, who would later carry on the family trade. Bennett married Emma Alderson Gray, and together they raised two children, continuing the Nance legacy in Coleman. Over the years, J. H. remarried and remained deeply connected to both his craft and his community.
His saddle shop, located on the east side of Commercial Avenue in the first block, became a recognizable landmark. Adding to its character was the life-size white horse â a replica inspired by a horse owned by earlier businessman W. P. Rasco, who came to Coleman around 1877. This figure served as both advertisement and attraction, delighting children who visited town on Saturdays and climbed aboard for a moment of frontier imagination.
Beyond the shop, J. H. maintained a small farm just north of town, across the railroad tracks off Colorado Street. There, he kept horses and lived in a large home with a wide, welcoming front porch â a reflection of both his success and his hospitality.
J. H. Nance passed away on June 20, 1937, and was laid to rest in Coleman. His son Bennett continued the business, upholding a reputation as one of the finest saddle makers in West Texas. In just the first three years after taking over, Bennett produced two hundred saddles â a testament to both demand and craftsmanship. He remained dedicated to the trade until his passing on October 7, 1964, also in Coleman.
But the shop was more than a place of business. It was a gathering point â where stories were exchanged, cattle drives were planned, and neighbors connected. In an era before telephones were common and travel was slow, places like the Nance Saddle Shop helped weave the social fabric of the community.
The craftsmanship of saddle makers like the Nance family represents a blend of necessity and legacy. Their work supported the booming cattle industry that helped define Coleman Countyâs early economy. Every stitch told a story â of long rides, hard work, and the enduring spirit of the people who called this land home.
Today, while the sounds of the old shop may have faded, its legacy lives on in the history of Coleman County. The Nance Saddle Shop â along with its iconic horses, both real and replicated â reminds us of a time when skill, resilience, and community built the foundation for the generations that followed.
EDITED:
Prickly Pear - Coleman, TX opened in the same building as the Nance Saddle Shop. Owner, Annette Carrell, says it still had the old cistern in the floor when she bought it. "If you look closly at the very top you can still see RECulp and a date at the top in the tin." Carrel remarked.
â€ïž Stop by the museum to see the Old Gray Horse and learn more about the people and places that shaped our county â and help us continue preserving these stories for the future.
âDo you have personal or family stories? We want you to share in the comments belowâ
strong and we're just getting started!
Written by Hillary Martin Kilpatrick
Coleman County Museum | CHAPS
history from https://www.txgenwebcounties.org/coleman/colemancounty/family-history/nance,j-h-family.html