05/13/2026
On May 16, 1869, WIlliam "Bill" Kutch and Shapley Prince "Shap" Carter were making thier way back to the herd of cattle and drovers located approximately 5 miles southeast of the present location of Olney.
They had been on their guard since finding evidence of recent Indian activity in their area. Bill looked up and spotted a group of Indians, and as he and Carter approached the herd, they could see the drovers and the herd already surrounded by another group of Indians.
Bill Kutch recalled in an interview that they thought about making a run for it, but did not want to leave their friends behind so they rode sttraight through the group of about 50 Indians they had first observed and met their fellow drovers in the center of the
herd, surrounded by Indians.
Up until this point, no one had fired a shot. The cowboys yelled to each other to run for the brush and it became apparent one of the Indians understood English as they made for the protection of the brush at the same time. The Indians would arrive first.
Some of the drovers in the group were William Crow, John Lemley, George Lemley, Shap Carter, Jason McClain, Kutch, J.W. Gray, Henry Harrison, Rube Secris, Joe Woody, and a black man called African Dick, a cook.
At 10:00 AM, as they all broke for cover the shots began to ring out and smoke and arrows filled the air. The drovers, armed with cap and ball revolvers, they were outnumbered and outgunned and were forced to retreat to a small depression on the grassy landscape.
The low area the had found for cover was a small ravine leading to one of the many small tributaries of Salt Creek. WIlliam Crow fell into the small area of cover, already dead from a gunshot wound to the head, and Jason McClain and J.W. Gray were already seriously wounded.
During the next seven hours of battle, most of the party would be wounded in the scant cover they had taken refuge in. George Lemley, John Lemley, Rube Segress, Shapp Carter, and Jim Gray had all been hit twice by gunshots or arrows, and BIll Kutch had been wounded three times. Jesse McClain had been hit once; leaving Henry Harrison, Joe Woody and the African, Dick, the only members not wounded. They had wounded at least five or six of the Indians by their own score and towards five in the afternoon they watched as the tribe had drawn up and could be seen gathered all together, taking orders from what appeared to be a black man.
In a desparate gamble , Captain Ira Graves told all the cowboys who could stand to get up and taunt the Indians. The Indians, having fought an extended battle all day and seeing the apparent morale of the cowboys, decided to break off the battle and leave with the herd of approix. 200 head of cattle and horses.
By the end of the battle, only Henry Harrison was unwounded. He rode off into the night to get help while the others awaited rescue.
By morning, a wagon arrived from the Harminson ranch. Three men, WIlliam Crow, John Lemley, and Shap Carter would die from wounds received in the battle. Two years later, Jason McClain would die from complications from the wounds he had received in this battle.
This is just one of the many battles fought for the land they call Young County and why we are known as the "Deadliest Prairie Crossing in the West."