10/20/2026
Under this Roof: The Tenant Timeline of Neenah Buildings. Today we will look at the history of 134 West Wisconsin Avenue in downtown Neenah.
This historic building has served many roles in our downtown community, starting in the 1850's. This buildings is the oldest commercial building in downtown Neenah and has witnessed a rich transformation from a 19-th century saloon, to a long-time hardware store, to a modern-day pub.
Here is a timeline of the various businesses that have been in this location:
*1856–1920s: Thompson's Columbian Sample Rooms. The initial tenant was a local sampling room (saloon) that operated for many decades.
*1920's – 1965: The Neenah Hardware Company had a long run as it transitioned the space from a saloon to storefront which served Neenah for over forty years.
*1965 – 1975: Storage space for the Kimberly-Clark Corporation.
*1976 – 1978: Granny's Restaurant – a short-lived eatery returned this space to the food and beverage business.
*1978 – 2004: Caliban's Restaurant – a very popular and memorable establishment held this space for over twenty-five years.
*2004 – 2007: Chatterbox – a new restaurant took over this for several years.
*2007 – 2008: Cornerstone Pub – held this location as another bar/restaurant.
*2009 – 2012: Five Generations Sports Bar and Grill – after significant renovations, the 5 G's Sports bar was a popular downtown location.
*2012 – Current: Greene's Pour House - The oldest commercial building in Neenah is now home to Greene's Pour House. This thriving bar and grill has expanded to include a banquet room on the second floor.