05/25/2026
Though many of those targeted during the Salem witch trials were poor widows, argumentative women, or individuals with scandal in their past, respected, upper-class citizens were not safe from the accusers’ pointing fingers in 1692.
Elizabeth Cary was married to a wealthy Captain from Charlestown, Massachusetts. When rumors reached Nathaniel Cary that his wife was among those suspected of practicing witchcraft, he believed he could easily clear this obvious misunderstanding.
But much to the couple’s disbelief, when the afflicted witnesses laid eyes on Elizabeth Cary, they appeared to become overwhelmed by invisible, tormenting forces. Like many other suspects, Mistress Cary was soon forced to undergo several folk tests. Though the magistrates had been warned against such controversial practices, they were used on numerous occasions as the witch panic wore on.
Mistress Cary was instructed to stand with her arms outstretched, forbidden to touch her husband or lean on him for support. The trembling woman was forced to look upon the afflicted to see if her gaze would increase their suffering. Her interrogators next brought her hand to touch a convulsing witness to see if physical contact would stop their pain. As she began to sob, she asked her husband to wipe away her sweat and tears. Though they had come to Salem Village to clear her name, Elizabeth Cary was soon placed under arrest.
On this day, in the year 1692, Mistress Cary reportedly suffered an extreme reaction to the brutal, unexpected treatment as she languished in Cambridge prison. According to her husband, she was overtaken by shivering convulsions that were so severe, he believed she may soon die.
By late July, Captain Cary appears to have given up waiting for justice. He quietly arranged for his wife to escape from prison. Though she was not the only fortunate soul who was able to flee to safety during the Salem witch hunt, this option was generally possible only for those with wealth and connections.