07/28/2026
DID YOU KNOW located next to the former location of the Over Easy Cafe on Tarpon Bay Road is Captain George Cooper's original homestead, built on his 160-acre claim. The two-story house was completed just before April 1891, when his daughter, Genevieve, became the first baby born at the Sanibel Lighthouse.
Born in Georgia, Cooper served as a drummer boy in the Confederate Army at age sixteen during the Civil War before later settling on Sanibel. He went on to farm, become a merchant, and become a community leader on the islands. Using material from the Calusa shell mounds, Cooper built Tarpon Bay Road to transport produce to his warehouse on Tarpon Bay.
Read more about the Cooper homestead in Ellie Dormer's history, "The Sea Shell Islands," available in our gift shop.
Photo Credit: Sanibel Public Library
A photograph of the old Cooper home on Tarpon Bay Road and Periwinkle, taken sometime between 1955 and 1965, decades after George Cooper sold the property in 1913.