04/23/2026
What happens when you get what you wished for.... by Greg Huddleston
"After a hot summer of digging and planting in the soil of two large gardens, of cutting and baling and hauling hay in dusty fields, of chopping and cutting and piling sprouts in every possible corner of the farm, and after all this to only then be confronted with endless lists of chores of every sort and kind and nature, a young boy's dream is to find an escape - even for a little while. That escape for my brother, Dave, and I was a dream of a horse. We could ride with the wind as we checked the cattle, we could easily best the worst desperado that might dare to sneak his way onto the farm, we would be more prepared in case any war party of Indians escaped off the reservation. Yes, a horse would be the perfect answer to our life of drudgery and toil.
Our prayers were soon to be answered in the form of a little, short-legged, cantankerous, spiteful, devious Shetland named Comanche. Mom worked at DeGraffenreid's store in Brumley and came home one evening telling us of a horse being raffled away on a splatter-card. (A poster board where you paid whatever monetary amount was asked - in this case $1 per chance - to draw an "X" on the card and your name placed beside it. Whenever the desired total was reached the board was placed outside as a target and then a shotgun was discharged at it. Whichever "X" was nearest a pellet hole that person was declared the winner.) Mom, knowing of our dream - as mothers so often do - had paid two dollars and placed my name and Dave's on the card. Dave won Comanche.
Dad wasn't exactly thrilled at the newest resident on Old Joe Branch Road. Comanche wasn't exactly thrilled either. Within the first day she figured out how to walk the concrete supports of the cattle-guard at the driveway entrance and made good on her first escape attempt. There were a multitude of more escapes that followed. We were correct. A horse would take our minds off the normal everyday chores. Only to be replaced by our already busy time now constantly preoccupied with a vigilance and awareness of Comanche's current location.
Comanche's rebellious nature left us with little choice. Dad wanted her locked up in the barn, but Dave and I couldn't stand to see such a free-spirit restrained and restricted to such a degree. It was finally settled that Dave and I would take responsibility for Comanche's freedom. We were given a 100' rope and told we had to keep Comanche on that rope at all times. We would tie her to a tree in the morning near a water source, and then move her every 4 hours or so to a different place. As we moved her from location to location we would take the opportunity to ride her. At one point it was my time to ride while Dave led her. I was jumping on and off her as Dave walked her toward the backyard. She kept trying to reach back and nip me during my shenanigans as it was apparent I was testing her patience. When Dave stopped to tie her to the clothesline pole he bent over to secure the knot, exposing a perfect target to Comanche. Since she couldn't reach me, she took it out on Dave.
We continued this routine for several weeks. Comanche actually seemed to become accustomed to our presence and mellowed out to some degree. One evening as we were leading her back to the barn for the night we were both walking alongside Comanche. Dave had the rope and, as was his habit, he had already wrapped the length of it around his arm, looping it between the palm of his hand and his elbow, keeping slack at a minimum. On this particular occasion we were accompanied by our beagle, Bimbo. As hounds do, Bimbo was paying little attention to us and was snuffling in large circles through the field around us. Bimbo, hidden in the tall grass, suddenly came upon his great nemesis, a cottontail rabbit. None of us saw the rabbit go by, but Bimbo's squalls of delight came straight toward us. Comanche spooked, up went her tail, up higher went her head, and away she went at a dead run. I stopped. Dave didn't have that luxury. He realized that the running horse was linked to his arm by the rope. Dave took off with great haste, running after Comanche, throwing coils of rope off his arm as quickly as he could. Bimbo was still filling the air with his sharp little cries of pursuit, having no idea of the chaos he had created behind him. Dave was now yelling for Comanche to whoa. Bimbo was going one way. Comanche, followed by Dave, was going another. This was becoming entertaining. I didn't think it could get much better, but it did. As Comanche quickly put distance between Dave and herself I watched in fascination as the rope she was dragging, that was invisible in the grass, suddenly popped up in the air. Dave's arm that still had the remainder of the rope wrapped around it seemed to jerk toward the fleeing horse, and Dave was instantly airborne, much like a water skier going over a ramp (except in a prone position). He looked like Superman taking off before gravity reclaimed him and he, too, disappeared into the tall grass. But I could tell where he was, and where he was going, by the wake being left in the parting of the tall grass that marked his passage. Comanche didn't stop until she reached the barn. Dave didn't quite make it to the barn. He was about 75' short. So much for Brumley cowboys."
More of Greg's stories are available on the MCHS web page at https://www.millercountymuseum.org/millcreek.html
Photo courtesy of Chuck Schulte