09/30/2026
Water towers often have the name of the community painted on them. But in this case we've pixelated the name to see if anyone can recognize where, when, and why this picture from our photo archives was taken. Any guesses?
edit: At this point it seems like the comments have come to the conclusion that this water tower picture is from Edgar—and you are absolutely right. This is the current Edgar water tower along with the one it replaced in 1980-81, located on the north end of the village between 2nd Ave and 3rd Ave (just south of Nicolet Bank).
The first water tower in the Village of Edgar was built back in the 1930s, and for decades the tall metallic cylinder provided the village with water, while also commonly serving as a local landmark. For example, people interested in taking part in the American Legion’s annual duck hunt in 1979 were directed to their club house, which was located “3 Miles West of Edgar Water Tower.”
But by the end of the 1970s, the tower was showing its age and the need for a modern replacement had became clear. In January of 1979, a bout of extreme cold weather caused the tower’s internal valves to freeze open, and the malfunction made the water tower to overflow and freeze. While the unexpected ice sculpture along the tower prompted the newspapers to quip that it looked like “a popsicle for Paul Bunyan,” it was less amusing to local residents who could not access running water until it thawed out and could be fixed.
So in 1980, the modern water tower was constructed next to the existing site. At the cost of $174,000, this new tower would hold 200,000 gallons of water in the larger tank suspended above the village. After it was finished in the summer of 1980, the connections were switched over. For the next year, both water towers stood there together. But by the end of 1981, the old tower was torn down and scrapped.
This photo is one of a few taken in 1980 and 1981, and saved by Ben Straub as one of the last additions to his excellent, 4-volume collection of photographic history from across western Marathon County. We’ve attach a few more from the same series for you to see.